Mixing Every Beauty Guru's Eyeshadow Palette Together

Published on Oct 31, 2018
Yes, we did this. So I have done a few bad makeup science experiments before with my own nude lipsticks, foundations, eyeshadows, liquid lipsticks, and highlighters, and I've also mixed together every lipstick from Sephora, but I wanted to think more dramatic this time, so I bought every online beauty guru's eyeshadow palette that was currently available, and we mixed them together into one Frankenguru eyeshadow. What do you think it should be named?
Check out our merch here: fiendsbysaf.com/
If your size is sold out, we're restocking ASAP so sign up for email updates!
Game of Thrones Theme - Western Cover
via BenDanProductions
Kevin MacLeod - Sneaky Snitch
Creative Commons - Attribution 3.0 Unported- CC BY 3.0
Disclaimer: We only bought and mixed palettes that I could buy firsthand (still available from a credible retailer), so palettes that were released essentially from mid-2017 onwards. We also focused on gurus who post content primarily in English, just to keep it the experiment to one market.
Aspyn Ovard x tarte
Carmi x Makeup Revolution - Kiss Of Fire
Carli Bybel x BH Cosmetics
Chloe Morello x Ciate London - pretty, fun and fearless
Chloe Morello x Pixi - Romantic Radiance
Desi + Katy x Dose of Colors - Friendcation
Dominique Cosmetics - Latte
Dominique Cosmetics - Lemonade
Emily Noel x Makeup Revolution - The Needs
Emily Noel x Makeup Revolution - The Wants
Eva Gutowski x Colourpop - It's All Wild
Eva Gutowski x Colourpop - Vacation Mode
Huda Beauty - Amethyst Obsessions
Huda Beauty - Coral Obsessions
Huda Beauty - Desert Dusk
Huda Beauty - Electric Obsessions
Huda Beauty - Emerald Obsessios
Huda Beauty - Gemstone Obsessions
Huda Beauty - Mauve Obsessions
Huda Beauty - Warm Brown Obsessions
Huda Beauty - Rose Gold Remastered
Huda Beauty - Ruby Obessions
Huda Beauty - Sapphire Obsessions
Huda Beauty - Smokey Obsessions
Huda Beauty - Topaz Obsessions
iluvsarahii x Colourpop - $aucey
iluvsarahii x Dose of Colors
Imogenation x Makeup Revolution
ItsJudyTime x Pixi - ItsEyeTime
ItsMyRayeRaye x BH Cosmetics
Jaclyn Hill x Morphe - The Jaclyn Hill Palette
Jaclyn Hill x Morphe - Armed & Gorgeous
Jaclyn Hill x Morphe - Bling Boss
Jaclyn Hill x Morphe - Dark Magic
Jaclyn Hill x Morphe - Ring The Alarm
Jeffree Star Cosmetics - Androgyny
Jeffree Star Cosmetics - Beauty Killer
Jeffree Star Cosmetics - Blood Sugar
Jeffree Star Cosmetics - Thirsty
Kandee Johnson x Too Faced - I Want Kandee
Kathleen Lights x Colourpop - Dream St
Kathleen Lights x Colourpop - The Zodiac
Kristen Leanne x Urban Decay - Daydream
Kristen Leanne x Urban Decay - Kaleidoscope Dream
Laura Lee Los Angeles - Boss Babe
Laura Lee Los Angeles - Cat's Pajamas
Laura Lee Los Angeles - Nudie Patootie
Laura Lee Los Angeles - Party Animal
Makeup Geek - Always
Makeup Geek - Forever
Makeup Geek - I’m So Extra
Makeup Geek - In The Nude
Makeup Geek - Not So Basic
Manny MUA Lunar Beauty - Life's A Drag
Marzia x Winky Lux - Natura
Marzia x Winky Lux - La Frutta
Melissa Michelle x ULTA Beauty - Bring On The Glam
Nicol Concilio x Violet Voss
Patrick Starr x MAC - Goal Getter
Patrick Starr x MAC - Heat Stroke
Patrick Starr x MAC - Play With Me
Patrick Starr x MAC - Stay With Me
Patrick Starr x MAC - Sugah Mama
Shaaanxo x BH Cosmetics - The Remix
Shayla x Colourpop - Perception
Shayla x Maybelline - The City Mini
Soph x Makeup Revolution
Soph x Makeup Revolution - Extra Spice
Tammi x Makeup Revolution - Tropical Paradise
Tanya Burr Cosmetics - Jingle & Mingle Night Palette
Stacey Marie MUA x BPerfect Cosmetics
Karrueche x Colourpop - She "Fem Rosa"
BelleJorden x Makeup Revolution - Obsession Palette
Some people say Norvina of ABH was once a Beauty US-tvr, and she has a bunch of palettes.
Karrueche x Colourpop - Brown Sugar
Jeffree Star Cosmetics - Alien Palette
Huda Beauty - New Nudes
Amber Scholl - 24K Gold Eyeshadow Palette
James Charles x Morphe - Unleash Your Inner Artist Palette
Christen Dominique - Dominique Cosmetics Berries & Cream Palette
But based on the color breakdowns of those palettes, I do not think that their presence would have drastically altered the final #Frankenguru color!
This video is NOT sponsored!
Safiya's Instagram: instagram.com/safiyany/
Twitter: twitter.com/safiyajn
Facebook: facebook.com/safnygaard/
Assistant Editors: Emily Linden & Claire Wiley


  • HELLO FRIENDS!! yes, we did this. please look to the description for a list of palettes mixed and a running list of upcoming palettes that were not included! love u guys!! xoxo, saf

  • Who else was waiting for a James Charles pallet

  • To be honest I kind of wanted her to melt every bread or cheese together I wanna see it loll

  • What about Sister James?

  • The cartoon Patrick star then Jeffrey Star then Patrick star the guru

  • You missed James Charles

  • Where is sister James pallette


    • bluemonkey307 okay that makes sense now

    • His palette wasn’t out when she made this video. Check this video’s description

  • Hey! I’m kinda new to this channel I have only watched three of your videos and I subbed on the first vid I watched of u Ur so cool and u put so much effort into making videos 💖💖💖💖

  • Saf are you working with Mr.Beast??😎

  • Name it Tea Bag 😄

  • U need to get the jame Charles pallet ASAP

  • You should name it: The Tea is Hot, but Not Delicious (Chalky) or perhaps No Tea, Only Shade (haha.)

  • YOU FORGOT SOMEONE....James Charles 🥺

    • His palette hadn’t come out yet when she made this video. Check this video’s description

  • Is this jefree star approved?


  • Wowza! US-tv - Stephanie Valhalla. Giving away FREE 3 Tree of Life Pendants to 3 different people!

  • 5:40 there bout to get scraped scraped😂😂😂

  • I wish u included the James Charles xMorphy pallet

    • Oh ok

    • It wasn’t out yet when she made this video. Check this video’s description

  • This was so painfull


  • It kind of bothers me that tyler foes so much for this channel and yet everything is safiya's. Idk maybe i just dont see the credit being given but

  • I think Safiya’s makeup room needs professionally organized again...

  • 0:44 james charles relly

  • I love how a few months after this video the most iconic palette came out *james Charles X morphie*

  • *”I birthed an eyeshadow”*

  • 13:24 that would be so cool

  • Wait i Live in the UK I thought I lived in beeeeeeeeeeeep

  • what about sister James

    • His palette wasn’t out when she made this video. Check the video’s description

  • #Safty! You guys are soooooooo cute!

  • She forgot James Charles

  • Guess what color it will be at 11:26 glittery black

  • U missed James

    • it was filmed before it was out

  • You should do mixing all the fenty foundations together

  • Why didn't you do all of the makeup 😭

  • is michelle phan still a booty guru??

  • I really want her to make a franken blush.

  • Ebbbbic

  • 0:31=WHAT!??!

  • Did safiya gain weight recently? Cause girls looking goodddd

  • this is so unproblematic I love it

  • What about James Charles?

    • His palette wasn’t out yet when she made this video. Check this video’s description

  • Saf maybe you could see if maybe you could get your own makeup line! 🤪

  • So sAAweeee 😂

  • Where did u get that thing that u pressed the eye shadow with

  • 11:58 simply nailogical???

  • Polish Mountain WHO???????*cristine is quaking in her chair*

  • Where from illinois are you from???

  • Did anyone realize that there was no JAMES CHARLES PALLET!!???

    • MMV4799 I’m sorry that I didn’t check the date!

    • If you are so good at realizing, you should of realised that this video was filmed before the pallet was out

    • I DID!

  • sorry but you missed james Charles ps love you Safia

  • Am I the only one thinking , sister where is James Charles hmm?(yes I did read the description I mean in the actual vid, he already has other palettes)❤️❤️

  • Oh my gosh where is Jeffree star

  • I luv how supportive Tyler is soo unlike Ben but h cant blame him when he is known as the drink slave

  • How about James Charles Morph palette

    • Wasn’t out yet when she made this video. Check this video’s description

  • next time i have to do science homework i'm just going to start watching safiya's bad makeup science videos

  • i need that carli bybell palette

  • Is it just me our was this video so satisfying

  • you should do a giveaway of all of these pallets. or just some

  • You should do a face full of the Frankenstein makeup you have created and wear it around for 24 hours.

  • You should’ve use the James Charles X Morphe pallete

  • i just won no.1 on flippy race lollll

  • Where’s james

  • i wached the engagement video before this she said in this one im like a pigen but in the other one she said that shes a battttt

  • *_You should mix bath bombs together_*

  • Why not James Charles? !?!?!?

    • +MMV4799 oh true true i didnt even realize the publication date😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

    • Because she can't buy pallets that weren't out yet

  • You forgot James chales

    • How can she forget a pallet that wasn't out during the filming of the video?

  • What about James Charles?

  • I think the best thing about filming these videos is having an excuse to buy so many eyeshadow palettes, because like... eyeshadow, ya know? 😍

  • That franken guru shadow is beautiful!

  • A lot of pallets came out after this vid. Jeffree’s Alien pallet James Charles x Morphe pallet Sylvia Gani x bh cosmetics And a few others

  • Where is james charles palette

    • Jade Freeman OOF I Just Realized That

    • OrangePanda 🐼🐼 this was filmed months before that palette was announced

  • Now, crush it up again and add James and Sylvia’s Palletes😂

  • Do a full face of franken-makeup! Please.

  • missed oppertunity for no shade only shadow

  • Where’s James Charles

  • What about Sister James

  • You don’t have James Charles pallet

    • Ella M this was filmed months before that palette was announced

  • Thank god she dident destroy the James Charles pallete like the ungrateful sister Loren Godwin

  • Give yourself some care girl!!! You should not hurt your self to make videos for us.


    • +Jade Freeman oh, sorry didn't know😐

    • Tyrone Warrick this was filmed months before that palette was announced

  • I actually really like that colour of the eyeshadow ❤️😘

  • GURL *Where Is My Sister James?* lol

    • Oh Thanks *In Mind She Says:Omg im embarrassed Becuz Of How Stupid I Am *

    • LeahCuteCat YT this was filmed months before that palette was announced

  • You should do a video where you wear all your Frankenmakeup pkzzz

  • You forgot James Charles

    • Dubstep Pro this was filmed months before that palette was announced

  • 12:07 *jeffree star has left the chat*

  • *James Charles has left the chat*

  • Nooooo you forgot James Charles

    • harleen beesla this was filmed months before that palette was announced

  • What about James Charles pallet🌸

  • what about james charles?

    • +Jade Freeman well I didn't know so sorry jade freeman.

    • jumanah abdelhamid this was filmed months before that palette was announced

  • what are you going to do with all of the pallets

  • you should mix every perfume from a drugstore

  • It's so satisfying when you scraped off the eye shadow but I wouldn't do it myself because it hurts

  • You missed

  • Weres James Charles

  • Just letting you know you forgot James Charles pallet

    • Ivana Todorova It wasn’t out when this video was filmed

  • How dare you forget a James Charles pallet 😭😭 Ps that was just a joke 😂😂😂

  • It a just a matter of time before she posts a video called: " Mixing All My Mixed Eyeshadows Together"

  • hey, what about david star 😄😄 - love from Israel

  • Still waiting on that - living like an eyeshadow palette for a day

  • Franken Guru is a really pretty color on you, Saf! I actually really like it.