Mixing Every Beauty Guru's Eyeshadow Palette Together

Published on Oct 31, 2018
Yes, we did this. So I have done a few bad makeup science experiments before with my own nude lipsticks, foundations, eyeshadows, liquid lipsticks, and highlighters, and I've also mixed together every lipstick from Sephora, but I wanted to think more dramatic this time, so I bought every online beauty guru's eyeshadow palette that was currently available, and we mixed them together into one Frankenguru eyeshadow. What do you think it should be named?
Check out our merch here: fiendsbysaf.com/
If your size is sold out, we're restocking ASAP so sign up for email updates!
Game of Thrones Theme - Western Cover
via BenDanProductions
Kevin MacLeod - Sneaky Snitch
Creative Commons - Attribution 3.0 Unported- CC BY 3.0
Disclaimer: We only bought and mixed palettes that I could buy firsthand (still available from a credible retailer), so palettes that were released essentially from mid-2017 onwards. We also focused on gurus who post content primarily in English, just to keep it the experiment to one market.
Aspyn Ovard x tarte
Carmi x Makeup Revolution - Kiss Of Fire
Carli Bybel x BH Cosmetics
Chloe Morello x Ciate London - pretty, fun and fearless
Chloe Morello x Pixi - Romantic Radiance
Desi + Katy x Dose of Colors - Friendcation
Dominique Cosmetics - Latte
Dominique Cosmetics - Lemonade
Emily Noel x Makeup Revolution - The Needs
Emily Noel x Makeup Revolution - The Wants
Eva Gutowski x Colourpop - It's All Wild
Eva Gutowski x Colourpop - Vacation Mode
Huda Beauty - Amethyst Obsessions
Huda Beauty - Coral Obsessions
Huda Beauty - Desert Dusk
Huda Beauty - Electric Obsessions
Huda Beauty - Emerald Obsessios
Huda Beauty - Gemstone Obsessions
Huda Beauty - Mauve Obsessions
Huda Beauty - Warm Brown Obsessions
Huda Beauty - Rose Gold Remastered
Huda Beauty - Ruby Obessions
Huda Beauty - Sapphire Obsessions
Huda Beauty - Smokey Obsessions
Huda Beauty - Topaz Obsessions
iluvsarahii x Colourpop - $aucey
iluvsarahii x Dose of Colors
Imogenation x Makeup Revolution
ItsJudyTime x Pixi - ItsEyeTime
ItsMyRayeRaye x BH Cosmetics
Jaclyn Hill x Morphe - The Jaclyn Hill Palette
Jaclyn Hill x Morphe - Armed & Gorgeous
Jaclyn Hill x Morphe - Bling Boss
Jaclyn Hill x Morphe - Dark Magic
Jaclyn Hill x Morphe - Ring The Alarm
Jeffree Star Cosmetics - Androgyny
Jeffree Star Cosmetics - Beauty Killer
Jeffree Star Cosmetics - Blood Sugar
Jeffree Star Cosmetics - Thirsty
Kandee Johnson x Too Faced - I Want Kandee
Kathleen Lights x Colourpop - Dream St
Kathleen Lights x Colourpop - The Zodiac
Kristen Leanne x Urban Decay - Daydream
Kristen Leanne x Urban Decay - Kaleidoscope Dream
Laura Lee Los Angeles - Boss Babe
Laura Lee Los Angeles - Cat's Pajamas
Laura Lee Los Angeles - Nudie Patootie
Laura Lee Los Angeles - Party Animal
Makeup Geek - Always
Makeup Geek - Forever
Makeup Geek - I’m So Extra
Makeup Geek - In The Nude
Makeup Geek - Not So Basic
Manny MUA Lunar Beauty - Life's A Drag
Marzia x Winky Lux - Natura
Marzia x Winky Lux - La Frutta
Melissa Michelle x ULTA Beauty - Bring On The Glam
Nicol Concilio x Violet Voss
Patrick Starr x MAC - Goal Getter
Patrick Starr x MAC - Heat Stroke
Patrick Starr x MAC - Play With Me
Patrick Starr x MAC - Stay With Me
Patrick Starr x MAC - Sugah Mama
Shaaanxo x BH Cosmetics - The Remix
Shayla x Colourpop - Perception
Shayla x Maybelline - The City Mini
Soph x Makeup Revolution
Soph x Makeup Revolution - Extra Spice
Tammi x Makeup Revolution - Tropical Paradise
Tanya Burr Cosmetics - Jingle & Mingle Night Palette
Stacey Marie MUA x BPerfect Cosmetics
Karrueche x Colourpop - She "Fem Rosa"
BelleJorden x Makeup Revolution - Obsession Palette
Some people say Norvina of ABH was once a Beauty US-tvr, and she has a bunch of palettes.
Karrueche x Colourpop - Brown Sugar
Jeffree Star Cosmetics - Alien Palette
Huda Beauty - New Nudes
Amber Scholl - 24K Gold Eyeshadow Palette
James Charles x Morphe - Unleash Your Inner Artist Palette
Christen Dominique - Dominique Cosmetics Berries & Cream Palette
But based on the color breakdowns of those palettes, I do not think that their presence would have drastically altered the final #Frankenguru color!
This video is NOT sponsored!
Safiya's Instagram: instagram.com/safiyany/
Twitter: twitter.com/safiyajn
Facebook: facebook.com/safnygaard/
Assistant Editors: Emily Linden & Claire Wiley


  • HELLO FRIENDS!! yes, we did this. please look to the description for a list of palettes mixed and a running list of upcoming palettes that were not included! love u guys!! xoxo, saf

  • Stop saying p--n plz .-.

  • Why don't you have James Charles pallet

  • of course james drops his rainbow palette like the next day

  • She should've spilled the tea.

  • Come here and learn how to waste your money 💰

  • Nikkie tutorials??😞

  • If simply nailogical have "peel porn". Safiya have "pour-n"😂

  • Her look reminds me of Morticia Addams

  • What if u got every cheese u can find in the supermarket, melted them and combined them into one super cheese that u have to eat

  • My initials are DC. GIMME BACK MY MAKEUP! XD

  • 💔I genuinely love you and your awesome videos but I have the urge to comment and say it rubs me the wrong way when you have these massive amount of products which you simply ruin/waste for the sake of a video experiment when there are people (OKAY, me!) that can't afford *_any_* products at all. Still, all the love to you but DAYUM, it truly hurts seeing that 💔.

  • I'm in love with that color. I want it.

  • “Which is holo..as hell...biatch”😂

  • Any ARMYs here?💜

  • please name it “tea”

  • I'd really love that average palette.

  • What about James Charles!?

  • Where’s James chariles??????

  • I'm from Midlothian Illinois+ love you!!

  • Hahaha that’s so funny my name is Lucy and the eyeshowdow name is Lucy

  • #Frakenguru

  • I just made my own franken-shadow and it's so pretty! Mine is a bronze kinda color.

  • 23:21 like small fish in the cup

  • ummm james charles palette?..


  • Oh. You have the bubonic plaque...So sorry...

  • Hey is Carlo bybels palette good? xx

  • Can you eventually do a franken-version of all different types of makeup, and then doing a full franken-face?

  • Okay, my eyes hurt so much. But I couldn't handle it when you started scraping the Huda Beauty. I dream about those pallets in my collection and than I see this...

  • I litterally watched this w no volume what so ever.. i cannot stand to hear her talk 😫

  • I think it should be called 'The Martian' because it looks a bit like Mars dust. Looks really nice on you Saf!

  • This needs to be ASMR. ITS SO SATISFYING!

  • I am going to be Ms Critical here and point out it's not the MOST accurate conglomeration of colors because you didn't equally add colors, Safiya. Whether the palette was a tiny circle of a giant "tile" you still did the same amount ratio-wise so good try, but not quite the most accurate "medium color" possible.

  • *but is it Jeffree Star approved?*

  • Are you filipino or american

  • You forgot James Charles .shister is gonna kill you

  • It seems like "Alright!" is Safiya's catch phrase.

  • "No *shade* to anyone if we missed them."

  • Where was Jeffree Star?

  • Has she already done a makeup video where she used all her frankenmakeup?😆

  • You should mix all kinds of makeup then make a full face of that makeup tutorial

  • I would buy some Frankenguru eye shadow from you if you are willing to sell it. Let me know please. I REALLY REALLY want THAT shade of eyeshadow. It's absolutely gorgeous and exactly what I have been looking for.

  • I actually love this color and want it haha

  • OMG She used bretman rock 😮

  • Wiggle Wiggle Wiggle Wiggle Wiggle Wiggle Wiggle Wiggle Wiggle Wiggle Wiggle Wiggle

  • I ❤️ watching what you guys get into next So informative & interesting From Sandra in Orangeville On Canada

  • I'm from Chicago

  • Not polish mountain shadow mountain

  • You just missed james' palette

  • Faith Gilbert faithyjg@gmail.com

  • Name idea: That’s the Tea

  • 100% of these beauty gurus names sound fake

  • That must be a expensive eye shadow she is holding

    • Valentine Minten $1800 I did the math

  • Basics of colour mixing 🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️

  • Why no james

  • ( no rudeness intended ) but if you do another of these plz include Pony syndrome with her Pony Effect Eye Palletes :) thank u safiya

  • I used to live in Illinois then I move to North Carolina

  • Hey Safiya! What do you plan on doing with all those pallets? If you don't use all those eyeshadow palettes, you could always scrape them all into a larger container and make more fankenguru eyeshadow. Then, you can do a giveaway!! I really like the color of the frankenguru eyeshadow and would definitely love to try it!

  • No offense but u r talking so much

  • Ok US-tv, I watched it.

  • Real talk: why doesn’t safiya have a lipstick collab or her own eye shadow pallet? I would so buy i!

  • Hey why don’t you make a Franken lipstick out of Matt Sephora lipstick

  • Omg my heart hurts 😂😂how can you do that😂😂😍

  • -The only beauty guru's palette that wasn't featured was Simply Nailogical- -wait does cristine even have her own palette-

  • Why was it at 12:08 that it went all suspenseful like that???

    • +Wexford princess you're welcome. Look it up. It's quite funny

    • +Mia ooooooooh thanks

    • There was a lot of drama with the two of them.

  • Did you do the Mavycorn palette? It's Marvin Macnificent's palette and he did it with bh cosmetics

  • Dude, i like you and everything. But talk less in your videos. God damn.

  • Safiya uploads this video, and then right the videoafter James Charels makes a *39* diffrent shadows eyeshadows pallete

  • Does anyone know what microscope she used?

  • i love the eyeshadow color so much! i'd totally buy it

  • you should do something like siri choosing your makeup or idk

  • 14:22 who else saw Tyler in the mirror

  • this made me cry hahaha

  • If she waited she could have done James Charles

  • Yeah I'll go to bed early today I'll just watch a marathon of Saf''s videos first...

  • I want to watch this, but it’s giving me anxiety that she’s scraping the eyeshadow out of the pallet 😂

  • Why no sister James?

  • 18:12 gets me idk why

  • What about james charels

  • 10:10 sorry to patrick star what i said but it is pretty funny that your names are the same

  • patrick star omg lol haha 9:49

  • What about James Charles?

  • that asmr tho lol


  • what about james charles

    • no, his palette came out in august and this was out in the following october.

    • Maren Vaclavik James just recently came out with his palette. This was months ago

  • Hey aren’t you on ladylike???


  • "mmmm… Valid" - Safiya 2018

  • Thanks for posting these wholesome viddies Safy! I absolutely love the Frankenguru color and am happy to know it's a close comparison to Dior, its such a nice color.

  • Does anyone know what shade/brand lipstick Safiya is wearing? Would love to know so I can steal it! Muahaha...

  • A

  • hey~~~`do you earn the whole country salary why dont u donate some money instead of doing all that trash--------just comment

  • Such a shame she did this right before the James Charles palette came out!! Wonder if that would've skewed the results at all

  • You've been called *the science virgin* and I ain't mad.

  • i lovvve this video

  • Mix all of your concealers and you could mix all your blushes and you can mix your bronzers/contour

  • It would be cool if you divide all the palettes into sets of a few different colours so you can make your own Franken Palette!

  • too bad you missed the sister palette lol

  • you should mix liquid eyeliner next